| The Breath of Forgotten Places | ||
|  | ||
| 
 | Formaatti: CD-R |  | 
|   Tätä levyä on hyvin vaikea arvioida, sillä 
        siinä kohtaavat hyvin selkeästi tekninen osaaminen ja ikävällä 
        tavalla etäinen kylmyys. Se on kiinnostava, vaan ei erityisen nautittava. 
        Mutta toisaalta, ei ehkä tarvitsekaan päättää: 
        levy-yhtiö tarjoaa tätä kiekkoa pelkkien postikulujen hinnalla, 
        ja sen hinnan arvoinen tämä tutustumisretki uusiin tekijöihin 
        ehdottomasti on. Hinta-laatusuhde on kiistatta erinomainen, ja uskon vahvasti 
        että varsinkin elektroakustisen tavaran ystävät saavat 
        tästä huomattavan paljon irti. Jiituomas | ||
|  | ||
|  | ||
| This compilation, made with a very high 
        sound production quality, opens with Jebus' weird track in which 
        a thin melody runs nowhere for over 15 minutes, accompanied by things 
        such as birds. The piece breaks and changes in tone here and there, and 
        as it proceeds, the changes become more and more severe. From the boring 
        start it turns into excellent, thin art-noise. Directive 4's segment 
        is a short, strongly echoed "waves of sound come and go" piece 
        in an electro-acoustic vein. Green End Listening Station presents 
        undistorted guitar, played without any apparent processing for 12 minutes, 
        transforming the sound into something close to a drone. The idea is basically 
        very clever, distinguishing itself from the numerous similar but feedback-based 
        compositions already existing, but unfortunately the track doesn't stay 
        interesting enough. It's just good guitar, not a change of mental state. 
         
         Swn plays a 16-minute ambient piece, one that starts with clinical sounds and a structure highly reminiscent of the works of Dual, yet then becomes unique as a piano is introduced to the mix. As a composition the track is quite fine, and complex, but just like the preceding track, it does not stay intriguing enough. Ulysses Girelle (who as far as I know normally makes harsher noise) has created clear-toned noise ambient dominated by some few clinical sounds. Again, a structurally fine, yet non-touching piece. It seems to be lacking a widening of its sonic range from one spike to a full wall of sound. The Buff Monkey Ensemble is also using here an acoustic guitar sound and drones, but unlike the previous attempts, manages to create a piece that's very good on both the technical and the emotional level. Grinding rock-chords transform into a soundscape emphasized by sound effects near the start. At the end the track breaks into less fitting singing, though. The disc ends with Psychic Space Invasion, this time doing squeaky-based minimalistic ambient that has a top layer of extremely loose sound bits. This is by far the finest track on the album, a song in which small disturbing sounds create a harmonious whole. This album is very hard to appraise, because on it is 
          a collision of definite technical and compositional skills against a 
          clear sense of unpleasant detachment. It's interesting, but not very 
          enjoyable. On the other hand, it may not be necessary to appraise the 
          record at all: the label sells this compilation at the price of just 
          its mailing costs, and this introduction to new talent is definitely 
          worth that money. The cost-to-quality ratio is thus undeniably excellent 
          for a buyer, and I expect that especially people who enjoy electro-acoustic 
          stuff will get a lot out of buying this album. Jiituomas | ||